Menu of Broad Street Pub in Waverly, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Broad Street Pub, nestled on 371 Broad St in Waverly, NY, offers a genuine bar & grill experience that caters to both travelers and locals alike. This spot stands out for its unpretentious atmosphere and a menu that brilliantly balances classic pub staples with satisfying comfort food.

The sandwich selection is truly the heart of the menu. The Philly Cheesesteak, hailed by one visitor as a nostalgic reminder of home, arrives generously stuffed with tender steak and melted cheese, delivering that authentic hoagie experience. Other standout sandwiches include the Yuengling Battered Fish Sandwich and the Patry Melt, both priced reasonably and crafted with care. The Cuban Sandwich and Reuben add a depth of flavor with their traditional layered fillings, while fan favorites like the Buffalo Chicken and Pulled Pork offer hearty, well-seasoned options for those craving a bit of boldness.

For lighter fare, the House Salad provides a fresh counterpoint, often paired with grilled chicken and complemented by wing sauces, offering custom heat and flavor. Starters like Sweet Potato Fries and Tater Tots serve as perfect accompaniments—crisp, golden, and flavorful, embodying classic pub snack appeal.

Noteworthy is the emphasis on accommodating a diverse crowd. Whether it’s the vegetarian in the group finding ample options or the careful attention of staff like Meghan navigating picky eaters with patience and grace, Broad Street Pub prioritizes a welcoming dining experience.

The evening vibe transforms with burger specials, such as the pastrami burger—a savory and satisfying choice that pairs well with adventurous sides like pierogies, a somewhat unexpected but much-loved addition to the menu. Coupled with a well-curated beer selection on tap, this makes for a relaxed yet hearty dining occasion.

Service at Broad Street Pub consistently receives high praise. Friendly bartenders and attentive servers create a convivial atmosphere that draws patrons into genuine conversation and easy camaraderie. Whether it’s a late-night bite or a casual lunch after exploring nearby Waverly Glen Park Falls, guests appreciate the swift, affordable, and warm service that feels personal rather than rushed.

In sum, Broad Street Pub offers more than just food; it crafts an approachable experience rooted in quality ingredients, solid portion sizes, and a sense of community. It stands as a testament to what a well-executed bar & grill can be—a reliable pit stop where good food meets great people.